There are always a few questions that are valid questions but just off topic for this site. Product recommendations are a great example. Apart from flagging and commenting so the user understands why it's off topic, is it proper form to also go ahead an answer the question?

For instance, here is a question asking for a book. I know of a great book I used and would love to recommend it but I feel that if I answer the question, the poster will have gotten what they wanted and thus the incorrect behaviour (posting an off topic question) is being reinforced.

Should we specifically discourage anyone from 'answering' blatantly off topic questions for fear of encouraging the improper behaviour?

Scenario: (I just watched November Man last night;)

Some user (new or old) continually asks for product recommendations, opinions, etc knowing full-well that the question will be closed within a few hours (and perhaps even their account flagged/etc). That user asks this question because he/she has a good chance that some person will answer the question with their opinion (perhaps even if they voteDown/flag the question). The user continues to repeat this process because although the questions are getting flagged/closed, the user is still getting what they want (albeit in a crude way).

1 Answer 1


In my opinion, you should not answer the question for the simple reason that you would be encouraging anyone to do the same, like you've mentioned. Even if the person knows it's off-topic but chances are that he's going to get an answer anyway, he might go ahead and ask the question.

There's a reason why those type of questions were judged off-topic and let's face it, for example questions about product recommendations get outdated very quickly. Also most of the time, those questions can be answered quite easily by using Google.

tl;dr: IMO, flag, leave a comment if you want to be nice and move on to not encourage similar questions.

  • 6
    This is 100% correct. Only thing wrong is it's too "soft" - if you are flagging for closure, DO NOT answer it. Those are perfectly contrary actions. Leave a comment, by all means, but don't provide an answer when the question shouldn't have been asked. Sometimes, if the question is borderline, the fact that it has good answers might possibly save the question from closure. So, if you want it closed, do not answer it.
    – AviD Mod
    Commented Sep 8, 2014 at 20:19

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .