Okay so a few people have been here for awhile, and often times a question or answer comes along that amasses a huge score(whether positive or negative) that totally takes you out of left field because you thought it would never score like that. I've seen a couple of these myself that have led to me writing better answers and I was looking for sorts of questions that would take people by surprise and why so I can try to look a little closer at those patterns.

So obviously the question is: What question/answer(s) scored in a way that totally surprised you and why were you surprised?


One answer I provided I meant merely as an addendum to what I thought was someone else's perfectly great answer that had a good vote score already. I only wanted to provide a different perspective, and I wanted to add an additional useful answer.

My answer eclipsed the other answer and I rep trained for a few days.

Something similar happened a few days later, but there wasn't another answer. I figured someone else would come in over top of me with a more canonical answer, but even though more thorough answers were offered, my answer got most of the votes.

As a result, I think I learned something about tone. I think I might try to emulate the "Bears" too often in trying to provide an authoritative answer. In one case, I even interviewed a famous expert in order to come up with an answer to end all answers (it got 4 votes). But the attitude I had while writing high-scoring answers was much lighter and I took myself less seriously, I even avoided being complete. To quote Rory, they were "throwaway answers".

But, here's the thing: I'm not sure that my high point answers are good answers, and I don't think that I should make all my answers emulate them. They might speak to the audience and reach some inner curiosity: "I never thought of that!" or "I always thought that was true" or some such, but they aren't the answers I'm proud of.

  • This brings up a really good point actually that if you can't tell my other questions on here are all kind of eluding too: What makes a good answer, and what makes a high scoring answer? – Robert Mennell May 6 '16 at 22:17
  • 2
    @RobertMennell perhaps votes are not a vote for your answer, per se, but a vote for the voter for being smart enough to agree with the answer. It's an "I'm with this guy" connection. The more an answer reaches the reader's self-identity, the more it prompts the act of voting. – schroeder May 6 '16 at 23:09
  • 2
    Oh god that's a terrifying concept. That means we'll written informative posts could be outdone by a horrible meme based explinations... – Robert Mennell May 6 '16 at 23:13

For me it was a throwaway question I wrote for Hat Dash. It scored ten times as much as my next most popular question:

How can someone go off-web, and anonymise themselves after a life online?

I think this one also attracted more answers than any of my other questions.

  • 1
    One of my skills is time travel. You've seen my precambrian work, yes? – Rory Alsop May 6 '16 at 22:14

Obviously I've had a few of these myself, and the one that really took me by surprise was Is there a legitimate reason I should be required to use my company's computer? (BYOD prohibited) since I thought this was pretty common knowledge and steps, but still I answered anyways expecting it to just be a reference at some point with a few points, and not explode like it did. That question even got featured in the newsletter and I never would have guessed that people would be so adverse to having to use company hardware.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .