11

We had some great sucess with eliminating the pointless tag recently. I would like to continue the quest to rid the world of bad tags by proposing a new candidate for burnination: . It is used for a multitude of purposes:

  • CSRF tokens
  • OAuth tokens
  • Authentication tokens
  • Session IDs
  • The beloved South Park character.

Just like file, the concept is both broad and vague. No one would say "I am a token expert" on a job interview. No one would say "Hey, I have a question about tokens" to a collegue. The natural follow up question to both is "Well, what kind of token are you talking about?".

There is a usage excerpt, but it was added recently and does not reflect how the tag is used:

An "authentication token" is either a hardware device, or piece of data used as part of an authentication mechanism.

So, this is what I propose: Questions about CSRF tokens should be tagged with . Questions about OAuth tokens should be tagged with . I think you see the pattern here. Questions about X-tokens should be tagged with X, not token. (Actually, I think a lot of these questions are tagged with token just because the OP wanted to tag with "X token" but didn't know that you can't have a space in a tag name.) Questions about generating secure random tokens should be tagged with . If there is a need for a tags matching the current tag wiki quoted above, they should be called and/or .

We are dealing with a lot of questions here - 110, and counting. If we do this, we should do it slowly so as not to spam the main page. It does not matter if this takes some time. It is also encouraged to fix other flaws in questions while editing them.

So, what do you think? Should the tag be burninated? If not, what should be done to fix it? Any additions or changes to my retagging suggestions?

  • 4
    Non-regular user browsing the meta: this seems like a good suggestion. – user2943160 Jul 9 '16 at 16:41
1

Nobody protested, so I assume this is OK. Unless I hear some protest within the coming few days, I will start to retag (ever so slowly, to avoid flooding the homepage) according to the rules described in the quesiton. Feel free to join in if you want to.

  • I have updated the tag excerpt and started retagging questions. – Anders Jan 5 '17 at 17:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .