10

Machines are taking over the chat. That is, there are currently more posts by the feed bot than actual user activity. So, couldn't we drop the feeds that aren't security-related? We would also make the chat look more inviting and on-topic by not burying the rare signs of human activity between unrelated feeds.

xkcd feed: Other sites have democratically decided to remove the xkcd feed from their chats and I think the same arguments would work for the DMZ. The majority of xkcd strips isn't about security - and those that are could be posted manually.

SO Blog feed: It's nice to stay informed about the developments at SO but since new blog posts are also prominently announced in the sidebar on every page, it wouldn't be necessary to auto-post them in chat.

Do we want to keep having all xkcd strips and SO Blog articles auto-posted in chat?

3
  • 1
    I'm supportive of this, but let's give it a few days so that people can comment (some may be off on holiday at present as well - kids are off school at the moment here, for example) – Rory Alsop Apr 4 '17 at 9:12
  • @RoryAlsop I agree that there is no hurry - waiting a bit will not hurt anyone. – Anders Apr 5 '17 at 9:54
  • @RoryAlsop If you find the time, would you like to use your moderator super powers to edit the chat feeds? – Arminius Apr 26 '17 at 1:22
8

No, we do not need them. Yes, please remove them.

While I (like everybody else) love XKCD, there is no need for it in chat. If I want to read it, I know where to find it. (Plus, it should be read together with the title which is not posted in chat.)

The blog feed is at least a bit more on topic, but nine times out of ten it is just promotion of something I don't want to read anyway (like another episode of the podcast or some random silly data analysis).

Instead of being spoon fed mostly irrelevant content from a bot, I think it would be better if we the users post things we think others can be interested in.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .