5

Should users say thanks either in the comments or in the question itself?

10

I doubt it brings anything to the discussion, it only creates noise. Site will take longer to load if everyone will say thanks (yeah, not that much, but...), so I think it is not necessary.

3
  • 9
    A better way to show appreciation of someone's contribution is an acceptance and/or upvote.
    – Gary
    Nov 12 '10 at 0:31
  • How about just still using commenting for thanks? The bits in comments don't weigh as much so it won't affect the page load time. :P Nov 25 '10 at 8:57
  • @Ilari - Comments may not affect the pages size in bytes too much, but they do have significant impact on the readability of the page and the vertical space taken by single question/answer posts that have a bunch of comments attached.
    – Iszi
    Jan 5 '11 at 20:55
7

I agree with @Pawel, though if you are responding anyway it doesnt hurt to throw in another word of appreciation.
Also, if someone took the time to write a long, comprehensive, or thoughtful answer, I think you could show your appreciation by discussing the content. Or, upvoting always works too :)

1
  • 6
    I agree with you, if in a comment you are already going to say something, you can say thanks if you wish to. But you shouldn't in the answer or the question.
    – James T
    Nov 11 '10 at 23:29
2

@Bubby4j - Thanks for the question. I'm sure users new to the SE environment will be interested in this issue.

Appreciation is always nice to receive, as well as polite and friendly to give. However, as this is a Q&A site with other means in place of showing (albeit anonymously) your gratitude, it is not something that should solely comprise the content of a post - whether it be a question, answer, or comment.

While comments may not greatly affect the loading weight of a page, they do have a measurable impact on the vertical real estate that is taken up by the question or answer post to which they are attached. Over-commenting, even by only one or two, can quickly make a question or answer look very bloated and the entire thread just becomes cumbersome and unpleasant to scroll through.

If you're making a post that actually furthers the discussion in some way, by all means do include an expression of your thanks in that post as long as you have enough characters left in your limit (if applicable) to do so.

Otherwise, please don't make a post for the sole purpose of saying "thanks". That's what up-votes and answer acceptance are for. People do notice the bumps in their rep, and the numbers next to their posts, so your appreciation (while it may not be attributed) will assuredly not go unnoticed.

Thanks.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .